| The Baseballist's All-Time Team |
| Position |
Rank |
Name |
| Catcher |
1 |
Josh Gibson |
| Catcher |
2 |
Johnny Bench |
| Catcher |
3 |
Louis Santop |
| Catcher |
4 |
Yogi Berra |
| Catcher |
5 |
Biz Mackey |
| First Base |
1 |
Lou Gehrig |
| First Base |
2 |
Jimmie Foxx |
| First Base |
3 |
Buck Leonard |
| First Base |
4 |
Hank Greenberg |
| First Base |
5 |
Luke Easter |
| Second Base |
1 |
Eddie Collins |
| Second Base |
2 |
Joe Morgan |
| Second Base |
3 |
Rogers Hornsby |
| Second Base |
4 |
Bill Monroe |
| Second Base |
5 |
Jackie Robinson |
| Shortstop |
1 |
Honus Wagner |
| Shortstop |
2 |
Pop Lloyd |
| Shortstop |
3 |
Willie Wells |
| Shortstop |
4 |
Arky Vaughan |
| Shortstop |
5 |
Dick Lundy |
| Third Base |
1 |
Mike Schmidt |
| Third Base |
2 |
George Brett |
| Third Base |
3 |
Eddie Mathews |
| Third Base |
4 |
Ray Dandrdige |
| Third Base |
5 |
Frank Baker |
| Left Field |
1 |
Turkey Stearnes |
| Left Field |
2 |
Ted Williams |
| Left Field |
3 |
Stan Musial |
| Left Field |
4 |
Pete Hill |
| Left Field |
5 |
Joe Jackson |
| Centerfield |
1 |
Ty Cobb |
| Centerfield |
2 |
Oscar Charleston |
| Centerfield |
3 |
Willie Mays |
| Centerfield |
4 |
Cristobal Torriente |
| Centerfield |
5 |
Cool Papa Bell |
| Right Field |
1 |
Babe Ruth |
| Right Field |
2 |
Hank Aaron |
| Right Field |
3 |
Frank Robinson |
| Right Field |
4 |
Martin Dihigo |
| Right Field |
5 |
Roberto Clemente |
| Right-Handed Pitcher |
1 |
Walter Johnson |
| Right-Handed Pitcher |
2 |
Grover Cleveland Alexander |
| Right-Handed Pitcher |
3 |
Bob Gibson |
| Pitcher |
4 |
Smokey Joe Williams |
| Pitcher |
5 |
Satchel Paige |
| Left-Handed Pitcher |
1 |
Lefty Grove |
| Left-Handed Pitcher |
2 |
Bill Foster |
| Left-Handed Pitcher |
3 |
Sandy Koufax |
| Left-Handed Pitcher |
4 |
Warren Spahn |
| Left-Handed Pitcher |
5 |
Carl Hubbell |
