| Robert W. Cohen's All-Time All-Star Team |
| (First Team) |
| Name |
POS |
| Josh Gibson |
C |
| Lou Gehrig |
1B |
| Rogers Hornsby |
2B |
| Mike Schmidt |
3B |
| Honus Wagner |
SS |
| Hank Aaron |
LF |
| Willie Mays |
CF |
| Babe Ruth |
RF |
| Pete Rose |
UT |
| Ted Williams |
DH |
| Walter Johnson |
RHP |
| Lefty Grove |
LHP |
| Dennis Eckersley |
Relief Pitcher |
| Robert W. Cohen's All-Time All-Star Team |
| (Second Team) |
| Johnny Bench |
C |
| Jimmie Foxx |
1B |
| Charlie Gehringer |
2B |
| George Brett |
3B |
| Ernie Banks |
SS |
| Ty Cobb |
LF |
| Joe DiMaggio |
CF |
| Frank Robinson |
RF |
| Jackie Robinson |
UT |
| Stan Musial |
DH |
| Christy Mathewson |
RHP |
| Sandy Koufax |
LHP |
| Rollie Fingers |
Relief Pitcher |
| Robert W. Cohen's All-Time All-Star Team |
| 1900-1950 (First Team) |
| Name |
POS |
| Josh Gibson |
C |
| Lou Gehrig |
1B |
| Rogers Hornsby |
2B |
| Pie Traynor |
3B |
| Honus Wagner |
SS |
| Ty Cobb |
LF |
| Joe DiMaggio |
CF |
| Babe Ruth |
RF |
| Jackie Robinson |
UT |
| Ted Williams |
DH |
| Walter Johnson |
RHP |
| Lefty Grove |
LHP |
|
Relief Pitcher |
| Robert W. Cohen's All-Time All-Star Team |
| 1900-1950 (Second Team) |
| Name |
POS |
| Bill Dickey |
C |
| Jimmie Foxx |
1B |
| Charlie Gehringer |
2B |
| J. Frank Baker |
3B |
| Pop Lloyd |
SS |
| Al Simmons |
LF |
| Tris Speaker |
CF |
| Joe Jackson |
RF |
|
UT |
| Hank Greenberg |
DH |
| Christy Mathewson |
RHP |
| Carl Hubbell |
LHP |
|
Relief Pitcher |
| Robert W. Cohen's All-Time All-Star Team |
| 1951-2003(First Team) |
| Name |
POS |
| Johnny Bench |
C |
| Stan Musial |
1B |
| Joe Morgan |
2B |
| Mike Schmidt |
3B |
| Ernie Banks |
SS |
| Hank Aaron |
LF |
| Willie Mays |
CF |
| Frank Robinson |
RF |
| Pete Rose |
UT |
| Edgar Martinez |
DH |
| Roger Clemens |
RHP |
| Sandy Koufax |
LHP |
| Dennis Eckersley |
Relief Pitcher |
| Robert W. Cohen's All-Time All-Star Team |
| 1951-2003 (Second Team) |
| Name |
POS |
| Yogi Berra |
C |
| Eddie Murray |
1B |
| Roberto Alomar |
2B |
| George Brett |
3B |
| Cal Ripken, Jr. |
SS |
| Barry Bonds |
LF |
| Mickey Mantle |
CF |
| Roberto Clemente |
RF |
|
UT |
| Harold Baines |
DH |
| Bob Gibson |
RHP |
| Warren Spahn |
LHP |
| Rollie Fingers |
Relief Pitcher |
