John P. McCarthy, Jr.'s All-Time Dream Team Lists
| Top 50 Best Hitters of All Time |
| Rank |
Name |
| 1 |
Babe Ruth |
| 2 |
Lou Gehrig |
| 3 |
Mickey Mantle |
| 4 |
Ted Williams |
| 5 |
Willie Mays |
| 6 |
Jimmie Foxx |
| 7 |
Joe DiMaggio |
| 8 |
Rickey Henderson |
| 9 |
Ty Cobb |
| 10 |
Frank Robinson |
| 11 |
Dick Allen |
| 12 |
Rogers Hornsby |
| 13 |
Hank Aaron |
| 14 |
Johnny Mize |
| 15 |
Mel Ott |
| 16 |
Joe Jackson |
| 17 |
Hank Greenberg |
| 18 |
Darryl Strawberry |
| 19 |
Eddie Mathews |
| 20 |
Willie McCovey |
| 21 |
Dan Brouthers |
| 22 |
Stan Musial |
| 23 |
Honus Wagner |
| 24 |
Tris Speaker |
| 25 |
Joe Morgan |
| 26 |
Harry Stovey |
| 27 |
Duke Snider |
| 28 |
Mike Schmidt |
| 29 |
Willie Stargell |
| 30 |
Ross Barnes |
31 |
Dolph Camilli |
| 32 |
Ralph Kiner |
| 33 |
Harmon Killebrew |
| 34 |
Wally Berger |
| 35 |
Babe Herman |
| 36 |
Hack Wilson |
| 37 |
Reggie Jackson |
| 38 |
Ken Williams |
| 39 |
Pete Browning |
| 40 |
Roger Connor |
| 41 |
Billy Hamilton |
| 42 |
Harry Heilmann |
| 43 |
Eddie Collins |
| 44 |
Frank Howard |
| 45 |
Al Simmons |
| 46 |
Chuck Klein |
| 47 |
Nap Lajoie |
| 48 |
Ed Delahanty |
| 49 |
Norm Cash |
| 50 |
Hal Trosky |
| Top 25 Pitchers of All Time |
| Rank |
Name |
| 1 |
Roger Clemens |
| 2 |
Lefty Grove |
| 3 |
Walter Johnson |
| 4 |
Hoyt Wilhelm |
| 5 |
Pete Alexander |
| 6 |
Ed Walsh |
| 7 |
Mordecai Brown |
| 8 |
Rube Waddell |
| 9 |
Sandy Koufax |
| 10 |
Christy Mathewson |
| 11 |
Harry Brecheen |
| 12 |
John Clarkson |
| 13 |
Whitey Ford |
| 14 |
Kid Nichols |
| 15 |
Cy Young |
| 16 |
Dizzy Dean |
| 17 |
Amos Rusie |
| 18 |
Carl Hubbell |
| 19 |
Hal Newhouser |
| 20 |
Stan Coveleski |
| 21 |
Tom Seaver |
| 22 |
Bob Gibson |
| 23 |
Goose Gossage |
| 24 |
Sal Maglie |
| 25 |
Nig Cuppy |
| First Team All-Time Dream Team |
| Position |
Name |
| Catcher |
Buck Ewing |
| First Base |
Lou Gehrig |
| Second Base |
Nap Lajoie |
| Shortstop |
Honus Wagner |
| Third Base |
Mike Schmidt |
| Outfield |
Babe Ruth |
| Outfield |
Willie Mays |
| Outfield |
Mickey Mantle |
| Designated Hitter |
Ted Williams |
| Pitcher |
Walter Johnson |
| Pitcher |
Lefty Grove |
| Pitcher |
Roger Clemens |
| Pitcher |
Pete Alexander |
| Manager |
Joe McCarthy |
| Second Team All-Time Dream Team |
| Position |
Name |
| Catcher |
Bill Dickey |
| First Base |
Jimmie Foxx |
| Second Base |
Eddie Collins |
| Shortstop |
Cal Ripken, Jr. |
| Third Base |
Brooks Robinson |
| Outfield |
Joe Dimaggio |
| Outfield |
Tris Speaker |
| Outfield |
Hank Aaron |
| Designated Hitter |
Ty Cobb |
| Pitcher |
Sandy Koufax |
| Pitcher |
Christy Mathewson |
| Pitcher |
Cy Young |
| Pitcher |
Carl Hubbell |
| Pitcher |
Satchel Paige |
| Manager |
Casey Stengel |
